Researchers have used validated 3D finite element models to investigate how post-tensioning and steel reinforcement affect the seismic performance of segmental bridge piers. The study, published in the journal Scientific Reports, identifies design parameters that could prove to enhance the resilience of earthquake-resistant buildings, while supporting the benefits of precast bridge construction.
Study: Analytical investigation in the seismic response of segmental hollow core bridge piers. Image Credit: 4045/Shutterstock.com
Self-Centering Bridge Piers Offer Promise for Earthquake Resistance
Segmental precast post-tensioned (SPPT) bridge piers are emerging as a valuable alternative to traditional cast-in-place substructures due to their ability to facilitate rapid construction and offer improved seismic performance.
Download a free copy of this page here!
This construction technique involves fabricating the footing, column segments, and cap beam offsite, then assembling them onsite using unbonded post-tensioned (PT) strands that run continuously through the pier.
The unbonded PT strands provide notable self-centering ability, reducing damage and residual drift after seismic events. However, these systems typically demonstrate limited ability to dissipate seismic energy, potentially allowing the accumulation of damage under repeated loading.
To address this concern, researchers have incorporated bonded mild steel energy-dissipating (ED) bars across segment joints, enhancing energy dissipation without compromising self-centering. Although several experiments have explored different SPPT configurations, comprehensive analytical studies remain scarce, particularly those investigating hollow-core piers with varying design parameters.
Evaluating how factors such as column segmentation, PT strand characteristics, and ED bar detailing influence seismic behavior is critical to developing robust design guidelines supporting the wider implementation of SPPT piers in seismic regions.
3D Models Reproduce Bridge Pier Behavior Across 10 Experiments
This study employed detailed three-dimensional finite element (FE) modeling through ABAQUS/CAE 2020 to examine the seismic response of
hollow-core SPPT bridge piers. Validation was performed against 10 experimental specimens sourced from prior independent research programs that represented diverse geometries, material properties, PT strand arrangements, and energy dissipation schemes.
The concrete behavior was modeled using the compressive stress–strain relationship from fib Model Code 2010, with nonlinearities captured via the Concrete Damaged Plasticity (CDP) model. Reinforcing steel, PT strands, and ED bars were represented with appropriate constitutive laws, including unbonded lengths to mitigate fatigue damage in ED bars.
The FE models incorporated realistic boundary conditions and loading protocols matching quasi-static cyclic tests conducted on large-scale bridge pier specimens. Subsequently, a thorough parametric study was undertaken, focusing on a hammer-shaped hollow-core SPPT pier 5.7 m tall, consisting of footing, column, and cap beam.
The varied parameters included the number of precast column segments, initial PT strand stress, PT spatial arrangement and ratio, ED bar ratio, and additional unbonded lengths for ED bars with different diameters.
The objective was to isolate the influence of each factor on lateral strength, stiffness, energy dissipation, self-centering capability, and overall seismic performance under combined gravity and cyclic lateral displacements.
Steel Bars Increase Energy Dissipation in Simulations
Validation showed excellent agreement between FE simulations and experimental observations concerning load-displacement behavior, PT force variation, and failure modes across different specimen groups.
Parametric analyses revealed that increasing the number of column segments had negligible impact on cyclic response, energy dissipation, and stiffness when maintaining the same overall height and aspect ratio.
Enhancing the initial prestress in PT strands improved lateral strength, stiffness, and contact stress up to moderate drift levels (around 4%), although these gains diminished at higher drifts due to strand post-yielding.
The orientation and positioning of PT strands influenced residual prestress and contact stress distribution, with strands closer to the column edges reducing these stresses but minimally affecting global hysteretic response.
Elevating the PT strand ratio increased lateral strength and stiffness but introduced a trade-off: in the modeled configuration, specimens with PT ratios up to approximately 8% performed well at large drift demands, whereas higher ratios led to earlier failure, suggesting practical upper design thresholds.
Increasing the ED bar ratio significantly boosted lateral strength, stiffness, and energy dissipation capacity, with energy dissipation improvements exceeding 2000% at the highest ratios studied. However, higher ED bar quantities also raised residual displacements, thereby reducing self-centering effectiveness.
Providing additional unbonded lengths for ED bars effectively mitigated strain concentrations near segment joints, delaying premature fractures. Specimens with greater unbonded lengths (300 mm or more) sustained larger drift ratios (up to 8%) without failure, emphasizing the importance of this detailing for durability.
The combination of unbonded PT strands with adequately designed ED bars thus balances self-centering with energy dissipation, crucial for seismic resilience.
Findings Reveal Key Trade-Offs in Seismic-Resilient Bridge Design
This research advances the understanding of how design parameters affect the seismic performance of hollow-core SPPT bridge piers. The validated 3D finite element models prove capable of capturing complex behaviors seen in experimental studies, including rocking motion, prestress variation, and damage localization.
Overall, the combined use of unbonded PT strands and strategically detailed ED bars could prove an effective build strategy to produce SPPT bridge piers that are both rapidly constructible and exhibit superior seismic resilience.
The results provide practical design insights to guide future construction and standardization efforts for segmental precast, post-tensioned bridge piers in earthquake-prone regions.
Journal Reference
Mesbah M., et al. (2026). Analytical investigation in the seismic response of segmental hollow core bridge piers. Scientific Reports, 16. DOI: 10.1038/s41598-026-74039-9, https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-026-74039-9.